Some links may be affiliate links. We may get paid if you buy something or take an action after clicking one of these.
NY State Assembly passed bill that would require used e-bikes be sold with UL-certified batteries.
Should the bill (A.4389C) be signed by Governor Kathy Hochul, sales of used e-bikes could be expected to all but halt. Owners of e-bikes—even those from reputable manufacturers—would be forced to replace the battery in order to sell it. If the e-bike manufacturer has yet to offer a UL-certified replacement, then they would be prohibited from selling the e-bike in the state.
Some Assembly members voted against the bill. Assemblyman Andrew Goodell (R—Jamestown) noted that there are 65,000 e-bikes being used for deliveries in New York City and most of those batteries would need to be replaced to sell those e-bikes.
Should someone be found to be selling an e-bike with an uncertified battery, they would be fined $500—roughly the cost of a new battery. Should they repeat the violation within two years, the fine would jump to $1000.
The Assembly has also passed a bill (A.6811) that would require the New York State Energy and Research Development Authority (NYSERDA) to create a program that would provide new UL-certified e-bike batteries to current e-bike owners whose e-bikes lack a UL-certified battery. The program would provide the new batteries at no cost or at a reduced cost.
Sponsor
Sponsor
The question becomes, “Will this actually reduce the number of e-bike fires in New York?” Unfortunately, the answer is no. Based on Electric Bike Report’s research, the fires being attributed to e-bikes have been caused by e-mobility devices such as e-mopeds and e-scooters. We can’t say definitively that an e-bike has never cause a fire in New York, but in every instance where we’ve been able to examine photos of the aftermath of a fire, the device in question was not an e-bike. Replacing every e-bike battery in New York would not have prevented the fires we’ve studied.
New York could pass the requirement to replace e-bike batteries but fail to approve the program to subsidize replacement batteries. If that happens, we can expect the used e-bike markets in New Jersey and Connecticut to suffer a glut of used e-bikes for sale.
Our hope is that the language of both A.4389.C and A.6811 receives tweaks to include the full range of e-mobility devices, particularly e-mopeds and e-scooters. Should they do that, they will have taken a real step toward consumer safety, rather than a symbolic one.
Sponsor
Sponsors
Sponsor
Copyright
© Electric Bike Report
